Published on Thursday, April 10, 2008

music

Nine Inch Nails falls short on long album
By CHRIS KRAPEK
Last updated on 00/00/0000 at 12:00 a.m.

“Ghosts I-IV” - Nine Inch Nails

Rating: 4 / 10

None of the music on Nine Inch Nail’s latest endeavor is ground-breaking; anyone with a copy of Pro Tools and an Aphex Twin album could have produced the same results.

“Ghosts I-IV” is 36 tracks of instrumental work that Trent Reznor and his fellow industrial cohorts worked on for a 10-week period last fall. While none of the music is particularly the jaw-dropping, revolutionary work that NIN made in the ’90s, it’s a concept album with one clear concept: imagery.

NIN mastermind Reznor has described the album as being “a soundtrack to daydreams.” Each track sets the ambience for an imagined place in the listeners head. Some are subtle, melancholic, piano-driven songs while others are in-your-face-industrial-metal-bleep-blips. Regardless, each track is supposed to unlock or evoke a subjective meaning, unique to everyone who listens.

While some tracks like “Ghosts III - 21” sound like the recurring theme of “American Beauty,” others sound like the complete soundtrack to a video game. With 36 tracks, and two hours of music, it’s hard to stomach everything at once. Each track has a different sound, feel and length, so trying to personalize and connect with four volumes of instrumental work is harder than it looks.

Mediocre or not, Reznor deserves all of the praise that he gets when he’s talking to himself in front of the mirror. Reznor should be applauded for his contributions to music throughout the years, and for his passionate drive to stick it to the man after he left Interscope Records last year, but Reznor now looks to be in a part of his career where he just doesn’t care anymore. He’s going to make what he wants, whenever he wants and make a fortune off of it, even if his new ways of digitally getting the album seem sincere.

Die-hard fans of NIN will no doubt love this album because, face it, if Trent Reznor recorded himself defecating and added a bass line, it would be considered a masterpiece. “Ghosts I-IV” is a failed experiment, but it’s a solid attempt at getting people involved with music other than Hot 100 radio.


By Anthony Topper  |  Thursday, April 10, 2008  |  9:29 am
Come on, "anyone with a copy of Pro Tools and an Aphex Twin album could have produced the same results." How about this, "Chris Krapek falls short with lots of hyperbole."
By Taylor  |  Thursday, April 10, 2008  |  9:48 am
This is the worst review I've read to date on NIN. Obviously, you don't like Reznor or NIN. If you don't like the guy, just save your breath bro. It sounds really bad when you mention that 'anyone with a copy of Pro Tools could do it'. C'mon bro, you know thats not true ;)
By dee the bear  |  Friday, April 11, 2008  |  5:23 pm
itz a said thing in the world when a bitter 5yr old mentality man/child iz given space to share hiz one-sided 'i dont like him so im gonna be a meanie' wordz with the rezt of the humanz who unfortunatly have to breathe the same air az thiz booger flicker :)
By Mary Davis  |  Friday, April 11, 2008  |  7:36 pm
As disposable as this album may be, this review is poor to the point of being crass.
By Max  |  Friday, April 11, 2008  |  9:13 pm
Give up writing now before you further embarrass yourself, you still have the rest of your life ahead of you. Find something your good at, and give it your awl.
By Chris Krapek  |  Tuesday, April 15, 2008  |  1:00 am
I am a terrible writer. Goodbye cruel world
By Resist  |  Thursday, April 17, 2008  |  3:09 am
if Chris Krapek recorded himself defecating, it would be considered a masterpiece, to his momma!
By Charlezton \"Crunchiez\" Cortez IV  |  Tuesday, April 22, 2008  |  9:04 pm
nIN totally deservez negative reviewz. You guyz think your commentz are real funny, yeah it's really funny when I'm pulling Dr. Krapek's head out of the oven. Hey Dee the Bear you took my adding "z" to wordz knock it off or i'll defecate on you, you belly buttoz lint pickerz.
By Angus Young  |  Saturday, July 18, 2009  |  9:52 pm
Chris Krapek ended up murdering himself after reading the comments, the majority of which were written more poorly than the actual review (which wasn't half-bad).
Comment On This Article

All comments are moderated before being published. We will not edit your comments, but we also will not approve those that are abusive, off-topic, attack another poster or contain information we know to be libelous or false.

During peak weekday viewing times, most comments will be reviewed within six hours. For more detailed information, click here.

After submitting your comment, check below for a confirmation message.


  • Your name:
  • Enter text from image:
  • Your comment:
Question of the Day
Only who can prevent forest fires?
you
me

Sign up to receive Northern Star headlines in your inbox, delivered weekdays at 6 a.m.


Feedback? E-mail us.
Real-time updates of recently viewed articles on the site.

1  Cooking With Flavor: Ghostly white pizza

2  Live Blog: Barack Obama, Joe Biden and the...

3  Cold climates may not always lead to canceled...

4  Monster Madness: Cruella de Vil

5  "Back to the '80s" rocks the Egyptian Theatre