Opinion

Published on Tuesday, February 10, 2009

column

Podcasts, audio books convenient but should not replace paper books


By KATY AMES
Last updated on 02/09/2009 at 11:23 p.m.

Everything is affected by the suffering economy. As TIME Magazine recently reported, aspiring writers are taking a hit because some companies are suspending the purchase of new manuscripts. Thankfully, many writers have not been discouraged due to a new wave of technology and good old networking.

“It seems a ripe time for novel podcasting to grow. Traditional book publishers are struggling. Book sales are down,” said the Jan. 31 article “Podcasting Your Novel: Publishing’s Next Wave?” by Hector Florin.

The article mentions how a Web site, Podiobooks.com, is where many writers, who could not publish their books, went to share their work. Some were lucky enough to have their work published as a result.

“I think if an author is perusing the more traditional route of publishing a paper book, they may experience difficulty in this climate,” said Alison Lukowski, English graduate teaching assistant.
Sophomore English major Ryan Whitehouse thinks podcasts and audio books didn’t take off like they were projected to.
“They seem so disconnected from what you’re actually suppose to be reading and interpreting,” Whitehouse said.
Do podcasts provide all the benefits of reading?
A post called “Speed of Listening vs. Reading” on the Web site, Educause Connect by Henry E. Schaffer, read: “When listening to a podcast of a speech, not only am I limited to approximately the speed of a person speaking, but it is considerably harder to go back [and] review.”

However, there are benefits of podcasts as well. The TIME article described benefits like the ability to add different sound effects and a broader range of voices into the podcasts.

“I listen to podcasts and audio books nearly every day,” Lukowski said. “For me, the greatest advantage is the ability to multitask.”

Whitehouse agrees that podcasts are more convenient. However, he thinks there is something better about reading and interpreting the text yourself.

Publishing companies and bookstores were bound to suffer along with the rest of the economy.

Podcasts are a huge benefit as technology provides a less costly way for people to engage their minds. Although podcasts and audio books are a great source to obtain information and entertainment at a reasonable price, or free of cost, they should be used in moderation and should never replace reading in its entirety.


By Evo Terra  |  Tuesday, February 10, 2009  |  9:17 am
Who's spreading the rumor that audiobooks REPLACE reading print? Very wrong. Audiobooks are mostly consumed when you CANNOT read print. Driving. Or cooking, as the image illustrates. Odd mandate to end the article.
Comment On This Article

All comments are moderated before being published. We will not edit your comments, but we also will not approve those that are abusive, off-topic, attack another poster or contain information we know to be libelous or false.

During peak weekday viewing times, most comments will be reviewed within six hours. For more detailed information, click here.

After submitting your comment, check below for a confirmation message.


  • Your name:
  • Enter text from image:
  • Your comment:
Question of the Day
Only who can prevent forest fires?
you
me

Sign up to receive Northern Star headlines in your inbox, delivered weekdays at 6 a.m.


Feedback? E-mail us.
Real-time updates of recently viewed articles on the site.

1  Huskies to take on Ball State with bowl game...

2  Victims' information released

3  With sales slowing, companies use multiple...

4  Fatty's host to Rock, Paper, Scissors tournament

5  City police blotter Oct. 23